From Graham:

I'm not the biggest classical music fan in the world, but it seems to me that if you wanted to hear the best possible symphony, you wouldn't pick an orchestra composed entirely of cello players. So it always strikes me as a little strange to see All-America "teams" that don't pay any attention to positions or compatibility. All-America list, maybe. But team?

Here's the eight-player rotation I'd pick for a team to take on all comers (the substitutes must have played primarily off the bench last season)